Is obesity prevention as simple as turning off the television and having a nap?

Me and Cooper Napping

The title of this post is – obviously – a bit provocative.  However, swapping your favorite TV show for a quick nap might be more useful than you’d think.

Regular readers of Obesity Panacea will know that spending too much time sitting/lying down increases your risk for all sorts of health problems.  For example, prolonged sedentary behaviour rapidly leads to insulin resistance and increases the amount of fat in your blood in adults.  Excess sitting (especially sitting in front of the TV) is also associated with all manner of physical, social and psychological health problems in both pre-schoolers and school-aged children (especially excess weight gain).  If that isn’t enough, it has been estimated that every hour of TV viewing shortens your life expectancy by 22 minutes, and that excess TV watching reduces the collective life expectancy of Americans by about 1.4 years (details here).

In contrast to TV viewing, getting adequate sleep seems to be extremely important for good health, including weight maintenance.  This contrast is strange, given that sleeping and relaxing (while awake) seem to be quite similar, at least in terms of energy expenditure and muscle activity.  This got my colleague JP Chaput and I wondering about the potential benefits of swapping TV time for nap time.  The below editorial, published last year in the British Journal of Nutrition, explains our thoughts in a bit more detail.  You can download a pdf of the article here.  I’ve also embedded below a video of an interview I did last fall with Dr Matt Buman, describing some of his research on this very topic (Email subscribers can view the video on the blog itself).

Although obesity research has traditionally focused on the role of diet and exercise, the unique contribution of sedentary behaviour (e.g. sitting or lying down) has received increasing attention in recent years. In particular, television (TV) viewing has been frequently associated with weight gain in both children and adults independent of other risk factors including baseline BMI and physical activity levels(1,2). Like TV watching, sleep is an activity characterised by prolonged periods of reduced energy expenditure. Yet accumulating evidence suggests that adequate sleep protects against obesity, while short sleep duration is prospectively associated with increases in both total and abdominal adiposity in adults and children(3,4). These contrasting lines of evidence suggest that if an individual is planning to spend an afternoon on the couch, they are better off asleep than watching TV.

While the above may seem like an odd public health message, it is nonetheless supported by a growing body of research suggesting that TV viewing and sleep have contrasting effects on energy balance and weight maintenance. TV viewing burns energy at a slower rate than most other waking activities, which may initially seem like the most probable mechanism explaining its association with excess weight gain(1,2). However, a meta-analysis has reported only minor associations between TV viewing and moderate or vigorous physical activity(5) in children and youth, suggesting that TV viewing does not displace high-intensity exercise in this age group. Further, it has been reported that the relationship between TV viewing and adiposity is not mediated by physical activity energy expenditure(2). It is worth noting that it is also entirely possible for an individual to accumulate large amounts of TV time while still exceeding physical activity guidelines.

Although the relationship between TV viewing and energy expenditure is not yet conclusively understood, most available evidence suggests that it may be energy intake, rather than expenditure, that largely accounts for the relationship between TV viewing and weight gain. TV viewing has been linked to increased food intake in both prospective and intervention studies. This may be partially due to exposure to food advertisements, which often promote unhealthy dietary habits, and may prime individuals for future food intake. A recent intervention study by Harris et al.(6) has reported that exposure to food advertisements increased subsequent food intake by roughly 30 and 45 % in adults and children, respectively. TV viewing also provides opportunities for snacking, and is associated with an increased intake of high-energy foods and passive overconsumption(2). Intervention studies that impose a reduction in TV viewing among children have consistently reported reductions in body weight(1), which may be moderated through reductions in food intake(7). These findings suggest that TV viewing has a relatively strong positive association with food intake in both adults and children. As with TV viewing, people burn energy slowly while asleep. Reducing time spent sleeping could therefore theoretically provide an individual with more opportunities for increased energy expenditure. Nevertheless, some evidence suggests that partial sleep deprivation may actually be associated with decreased energy expenditure through fatigue-related reductions in physical activity and lowered body temperature(3). This remains controversial, however, as more recent studies have found little evidence linking partial sleep deprivation to changes in total energy expenditure, RMR or physical activity(4). Thus, as with TV viewing, available evidence suggests that energy expenditure is not the primary mechanism linking insufficient sleep with increased adiposity.

Current evidence suggests that sleep duration is negatively associated with both acute and chronic food intake. Sleep restriction is known to increase food intake in both human subjects and animal models, and seems to predispose individuals towards increased intake of energy-dense foods that are high in fats and carbohydrates(4). These effects on food intake are probably related to changes in homeostatic (e.g.hormonal) and/or hedonic (e.g. reward-seeking) feeding behaviour(3,4). Insufficient sleep may increase the homeostatic drive to eat, as short-duration sleepers are known to have increased levels of ghrelin, reduced levels of leptin and altered glucose homeostasis(3,4).

Short sleep duration may also increase the rewarding value of food, which suggests that food intake could also be increased through non-homeostatic mechanisms(4). Finally, reduced sleep may simply offer individuals increased opportunities for energy intake(3,4). This impact may be especially strong when extra waking hours are spent watching TV, which may further stimulate food intake(4). Collectively, this evidence suggests that inadequate sleep may have a substantial impact on energy intake, and thereby energy balance and body weight.

The above evidence suggests that TV viewing and sleep exert opposing influences on energy balance and body weight. It is also worth noting that the relationships of both sleep and TV viewing with obesity appear to be stronger in the paediatric age group(2,3). TV viewing tends to stimulate food intake, while an obesogenic environment exacerbates this problem with easy access to energy-dense and palatable foods. In contrast, the activity of sleeping is ‘satiating’ from biological and environmental perspectives since it reduces the drive to eat, opportunities for food intake, and exposure to external food-related cues. Although speculative, it is plausible that a few hours of napping on the couch could have a vastly different (and more positive) impact on weight maintenance than an equivalent amount of TV viewing. This raises an obvious question: if you are concerned about your body weight, is it better to sleep through your favourite TV show rather than watching it?

It is perhaps time that clinicians urge their patients to not only reduce their daily amount of TV viewing, but to also replace that TV time with a good night’s sleep. Interventions that focus on increasing sleep time or reducing TV viewing may prove easier to implement than those focused specifically on diet or exercise. Available evidence already suggests that reducing TV time is an effective means of reducing body weight in children and youth(1,7), and initial reports have suggested that increasing sleep may improve mood and help reduce food cravings among obese adults(4). Reducing TV viewing and/or getting adequate sleep require little in the way of resources or expertise, and may therefore be more sustainable than more traditional interventions focused on diet and exercise. If having a good night’s sleep truly is better for your weight than watching TV, this would be a lifestyle modification which may be substantially easier to implement than adopting a new diet or exercise routine. This change of focus is certainly worth consideration, right after a short nap.

References

1. Tremblay MS, LeBlanc AG, Kho ME, et al. (2011) Systematic review of sedentary behavior and health indicators in school-aged children and youth. Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act 8, 98.
2. Thorp AA, Owen N, Neuhaus M, et al. (2011) Sedentary behaviors and subsequent health outcomes in adults: a systematic review of longitudinal studies, 1996–2011. Am J Prev Med 41, 207–215.
3. Patel SR & Hu FB (2008) Short sleep duration and weight gain: a systematic review. Obesity (Silver Spring) 16, 643–653.
4. Chaput JP & Tremblay A (2012) Insufficient sleep as a contributor to weight gain: an update. Current Obesity Rep (In Press).
5. Marshall SJ, Biddle SJH, Gorely T, et al. (2004) Relationships between media use, body fatness and physical activity in children and youth: a meta-analysis. Int J Obes 28, 1238–1246.
6. Harris JL, Bargh JA & Brownell KD (2009) Priming effects of television food advertising on eating behavior. Health Psychol 28, 404–413.
7. Epstein LH, Roemmich JN, Robinson JL, et al. (2008) A randomized trial of the effects of reducing television viewing and computer use on body mass index in young children. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 162, 239–245

© Saunders TJ, Chaput JP. British Journal of Nutrition (2012), 108, 946–947.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Creative Commons License
Is obesity prevention as simple as turning off the television and having a nap? by Obesity Panacea, unless otherwise expressly stated, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License.

This entry was posted in nutrition, Obesity Research, Peer Reviewed Research, Sedentary Behaviour and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Is obesity prevention as simple as turning off the television and having a nap?

  1. WRG says:

    Interesting but here’s my n=1 experience.

    I watch a fair bit of TV, however I never eat meals in front of the TV nor do I snack while watching TV.

    I am also an inveterate napper. I find that when I wake up from a nap, I am frequently voraciously hungry. I used to do a 45-minute guided meditation lying down (I still meditate, though it’s a different technique and I do it sitting up) and often fell asleep doing it. Whenever I woke up, I was terribly hungry.

    So, at least in my case, sleeping during the day–rather than TV watching–is associated with eating.

    That’s my n=1 experience.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
  2. Kathryn Barker says:

    Curious if prolonged time spent web surfing has the same overall effect as TV watching? My guess is that only the device is different and that the negative consequences would be the same.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
    • Travis says:

      You are probably right, although there could be some differences. For example, it’s a lot easier to eat while watching TV than while working on a computer (trust me, I do this quite often at work, and it’s never pretty).

      And of course it gets complicated to tease these things out when people stop watching TV on a TV, and instead watch everything on a computer or tablet (my wife and I haven’t had a TV for years, although we have a “TV computer” setup on our coffee table). So the magnitude of effect may be slightly different depending on the device or how it’s being used, but I think you’re right that the general impact is going to be in the same direction.

      VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
      Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
  3. Pingback: Is obesity prevention as simple as turning off the television and having a nap? | Today Health Channel

  4. Pingback: Is obesity prevention as simple as turning off the television and having a nap? « Tony Rocha Official Blog

  5. People assume that sitting around watching TV contributes to obesity. Although they are correlated, this doesn’t necessarily mean cause and effect.

    We believe that many people with obesity have a form of food-induced brain dysfunction called CARB syndrome. People with CARB syndrome develop up to 22 brain dysfunction symptoms and they tend to store excessive body fat at any caloric intake. Because they have low levels of dopamine in their brain, they have little energy. If you have low energy, you tend to sit around at home and watch TV.

    The TV watching actually has no role in causing the excessive fat storage.

    VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
    Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
    • Travis says:

      Hi William,

      Thanks for the comment. We’re not assuming that watching TV increases food intake from correlation studies – there are several randomized intervention studies which have found this to be the case, including those referenced in the above article. As a result, your statement that TV watching has no causal role in the development of obesity seems a hard to defend.

      That’s not to say that reducing carbs is a bad idea, but that hammer doesn’t work on every nail.

      VA:F [1.9.22_1171]
      Rating: 0 (from 0 votes)
  6. Pingback: A roundtable discussion on active video games | Obesity Panacea