Saving Ethiopia’s “Church Forests”

On Lake Tana by A. Davey, http://www.flickr.com/photos/adavey/2261540902/

In America, some fundamental Christians believe that man has a God-given right to use the earth and all its resources to meet their needs. After all, Genesis says so. But across the Atlantic, a different attitude prevails among followers in Ethiopia, which has the longest continuous tradition of Christianity of any African country. Followers of the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahido Churches believe they should maintain a home for all of God’s creatures around their places of worship. The result? Forests ringing churches.

There are some 35,000 church forests in Ethiopia, ranging in size from a few acres to 300 hectares. Some churches and their forests may date back to the fourth century, and all are remnants of Ethiopia’s historic Afromontane forests. To their followers, they are a sacred symbol of the garden of Eden — to be loved and cared for, but not worshipped.

Ethiopia, Lake Tana by * hiro008, http://www.flickr.com/photos/deepblue66/3222338148/Most church forests are concentrated in the northern reaches of the country, especially in the Lake Tana area. Here, most of the Afromontane forests have been cut down to make clearings for agriculture, pastures for livestock and settlements. It is said that if a traveler to the area spies a forest, it surely has a church in the middle. Many also have freshwater springs.

These spiritually-protected woods, also known as coptic forests, comprise a decent chunk of the 5 percent of Ethiopia’s historical forests that are still standing. Massive deforestation has rendered these church forests as true islands — green oases peppering a land laid bare.

“Connecting them to other forests is a luxury we can’t even consider,” says international tropical ecologist and researcher Margaret Lowman, because the lands between them are predominantly crop fields today. Fondly known as Canopy Meg to her colleagues, Lowman is a canopy researcher who has studied forests on five continents.

What remains is fragile. Isolated by habitat fragmentation, conservationists are grasping these church forests as centerpieces of the country’s fight to retain its biodiversity. These beacon-like green swaths have become refuges for all kinds of species — but no one really knows what is at stake because they are extremely poorly studied.

Awakening awareness

Alemayehu Wassie Eshete is an Ethiopian forest researcher who did his PhD work on his country’s coptic forests. His dissertation, and a few related papers, may form the entirety of the published scientific literature on Ethiopia’s forest churches, according to Lowman.

She met Wassie at a scientific meeting a few years ago. When she asked him what he was going to do next on coptic forests, he wept from frustration. With very limited economic means, and few international connections, Wassie felt he needed help with visibility and expertise to study — and conserve — his country’s forests. Lowman began helping him, and in 2009 he invited her to visit the forests in person. She went.

With Wassie’s help, Lowman  gave a PowerPoint presentation to about 100 men, most priests. Some had traveled for days to attend the meeting. She showed them images of their church forests.

Though some had never seen a computer, they recognized their forests and she says they gasped audibly at the pictures showing the  woods shrinking inwards over time. Lowman says they intuitively grasped the value of ecosystem services because, for them, it fell under the purview of their spiritual duties to protect the biodiversity around their places of worship.

Preliminary research by Tehri Evinen, a master’s candidate in forest sciences at the University of Helsinki, has uncovered in more detail how the priests conceive of their spiritual forests. “What [matters to them] religiously is the number of trees, not the ecological health of the forests” Evinen wrote in an e-mail. “The trees are said to be the jewelry of the church and the more trees a church has the more appreciated it is since the tree canopy prevents the prayers from being lost to the sky.”

Despite this, the biggest threats to these forests are not external factors such as industrial loggers or agribusiness, Lowman says. Rather, the biggest threat lies inside: the church members and clergy who use the forests for firewood, and rely on them for livelihoods.

The clergy and church members use the wood from trees to repair their church, to make charcoal for church activities, and to make sacred utensils. Plants in the forest are eaten or used to make dyes. Deadfall is sold to congregants for cash.

The trip ingrained in Lowman’s mind that engaging the priests and church members was a vital part of studying and conserving the remaining coptic forests.

Insightful insects

This past August, Lowman returned to Ethiopia and led a team of 13 scientists to survey several church forests on the south shore of Lake Tana and at a rural village about 60 miles to the northeast, Debre Tabor. The purpose on the team’s trip, hopefully the first of many, was to assess the insect biodiversity and the economic importance of the tree species remaining in these sacred forests.

“We didn’t even know if birds or mammals would be left in these highly threatened areas,” Lowman says. “We chose insects to survey because we wanted an index of something we hoped would be healthy. It would be awful to give the local people bad news right at the start. Mammals were worrisome because it may be they’ve all been hunted or poached. Birds were also problematic because the fragmentation level is so high. But also, pollinators are such an important part of ecosystem services that we thought being able to educate the local people about them at the same time would be useful.”

And this embodies the heart of how Lowman has conducted her scientific career: equal parts science and public outreach.

Lowman’s team examined every level of the forests: they climbed into the canopies, shook bugs from tree limbs, and set insect traps.

They surveyed the lower reaches and scoured the forest floor where dung beetles carry out important waste-removal processes. They surveyed ants, beetles, flies and wasps and counted birds, mostly in the surrounding fields. The team collected in the day, and during the night; rain or shine. By the end, they gathered data on 5,500 insects mostly from two forest churches: Debresena (outside of Debre Tabor); and Zahara, close to Bahir Dar.

A month before the research trip, Lowman started a new job as the director of the Nature Research Center at the North Carolina Museum of Natural Sciences. Part of the center’s mission is to communicate science to the public and actively engage children. So she live-streamed video of the field work back to the museum as a pilot project. Soon, the researchers garnered the attention of local children who watched, and even helped, the researchers collect their specimens. Lowman described it like this in the North Carolina Naturalist:

Armed with our nets and ropes and vials, we attracted a large swath of children who watched our every move and marveled at the six-legged creatures swept from the foliage. Despite the language barriers, we all laughed when ants fell on our heads, and shrieked with joy when a purple beetle appeared on the surface of our collecting tray.

When she returns next year, Lowman plans to further engage the children through educational activities to teach them about the importance of their remaining forests. Though 95 percent of their forests have been wiped off the map, the remaining forest churches provide important ecosystem services. They harbor pollinator species that forests and crops require, and they sequester carbon and conserve water. Wassie estimates that 1.1 billion tons of soil is eroded in northern Ethiopia every year. The trees of the forest churches help to hold a small portion of the landscape’s soil steadily in place.

Fences, feces, and farming

When people worship at the churches, it may be a several-hour to an all-day long affair. Which means that people often need to relieve themselves in the forests, where there are typically no toilets. Priests and disciples also live in huts in the forest, using it for nature’s call because no other facilities exist.

“We found a preponderance of dung beetles specific to human feces,” Lowman says. “So obviously the system is being degraded even without intent.” In fact, more than three-quarters of their faunal collections from the ground samples were these dung beetles.

When the team asked a priest what ideas he had for how the researchers could help them, he asked for toilets. Lowman says the original research project has now blossomed into fund-raising to help the communities build fences (to keep livestock out) and to build pit toilets. Her team calculated they need to raise $42,000 for latrines and $271, 871 for fences and walls. Lowman holds hope that improving the hygiene of the people who use the churches will not only build trust but will also enhance the health of the forests themselves.

Another opportunity Lowman sees for improving Ethiopia’s church forests reflects back upon the force that created them: agricultural. She says that if the farmers could get more productivity out of their crops, then they could use less land for agriculture. Some of the land could be reforested.

“But they need more food as the population increases. They are starving,” Lowman says.

“You can’t expect hungry people to conserve forests when they need to plant an extra row of corn or millet.”
Bose Corn Maze by John Biehler, http://www.flickr.com/photos/retrocactus/3961480238/

Lowman retains her strongest optimism for the youth of these areas. Which is not surprising since she has devoted a large part of her career to outreach geared to school kids, such as through the Jason project. (Because of her extensive outreach, children often write to her asking, “Dear Canopy Meg, How can I help save the rain forests?” For a start, she writes them back.)

In the case of Ethiopia’s precious green dots, Lowman’s research team is slated to head back in the dry season of 2012, and educational outreach to children ranks as high on her priority list as surveying insects and trees.

David Jarzen, a palynologist with the Florida Museum of Natural History, and a member of the research team led by Lowman, summed it up this way in an article written for The Palynological Society’s December newsletter:

The future of these church forests remains to be seen. Some of the team scientists are already planning a return visit to the region during the dry season in January or February. A closer, more detailed study of the fauna and flora, over several years, covering wet and dry seasonal changes of these forests is needed to fully understand the nature of the forests and strategies for their conservation. Whether these people allow their forests to remain intact, or cut into small plots as they are now, will determine the fate of their culture.

Which may be why Canopy Meg is investing in Ethiopia’s kids to help save their country’s forests.

Want more? Read Meg’s blog posts on Ethiopia here.

Funding: the second expedition reported upon here was sponsored by the National Geographic Society, the TREE Foundation, and the North Carolina Museum of Natural Sciences with additional support from the Tommy Hilfiger Foundation.

SOURCE NOTES:

Original interviews with Meg Lowman, Jan. 19 and Feb. 14, 2011.

Eshete, Alemayehu Wassie. 2005. Ethiopian Church Forests: Their Contribution in Combating Ecological Degradation and Climate Change in Northern Ethiopia. PowerPoint Presentation for the Society of Ecological Restoration. Access here.

Jarzen, David; Margaret Lowman; Susan Jarzen. 2010. Ethiopia: A Land in Need. PowerPoint Presentation.

Jarzen, David, Susaz Jarzen and Margaret Lowman. 2010. In and Out of Africa. American Association of Stratigraphic Palynologists. Newsletter. (43)4:11-14.

Lowman, Margaret. Fall/Winter 2010. CSI in Ethiopia: Children Survey Insects. North Carolina Naturalist.

Lowman, Margaret. Winter 2010/2011. Finding Sanctuary – Saving the biodiversity of Ethiopia, one church forest at a time. The Explorers Journal.

Guest Blogger Profile: T. DELENE BEELAND is an independent science writer, who often covers nature & the great outdoors. She’s writing a book (UNC Press), and is a frequent contributor for the Charlotte Observer’s Science section. You can find her on Twitter and on the Wild Muse blog.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
This entry was posted in Guest Post and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

49 Responses to Saving Ethiopia’s “Church Forests”

  1. Pingback: Saving Ethiopia’s “Church Forests” - Articles | Orthodoxy Cognate PAGE

  2. Observer says:

    Good job!

  3. adisuab says:

    Amazing! Thanks Delene for the detailed and lively reporting!

  4. Pingback: Saving Ethiopia’s “Church Forests” « Wild Muse

  5. Neil Hutt says:

    Excellent as always, DeLene. A friend who is just returning from a trip to the Bale Mountains of Ethiopia will enjoy this. And so would Claudio Sillero.

  6. Pingback: Saving Ethiopia's Church Forests - Wildlife Gardeners - North American Wildlife Gardening

  7. Ed Yong says:

    A really, really good piece. Did this spring out of Scio11?

    • DeLene says:

      Thank you for reading, Ed. This was not spawned from Scio11. Two months prior to the conference, I pitched a profile on Lowman to my Observer editor. (I originally met her at a Mark Moffet lecture at the N.C. Museum of Natural Sciences last fall.) Due to Lowman’s travel schedule, and my move to Asheville, I was not able to interview her until after the conference. This article came from that interivew, a nice story that we had no room for in the newspaper personality/research profile. Thanks again.

  8. Pingback: “Church Forests” of Ethiopia « AddisEthiopia Weblog

  9. Pingback: Open Laboratory 2011 – submissions so far | A Blog Around The Clock

  10. Very interesting article. Your first statement about fundamentalists is stupid… or more likely ignorant and unfortunate since it would throw some of us off.

    Anyway… after that stumble great stuff.

  11. Pingback: In the "Church Forests" of Ethiopia | Battery and Charger Forum

  12. Pingback: In the News: Meg Lowman in Ethiopia « Nature Research Center

  13. Pingback: Things to read and look at this week:

  14. mathew says:

    Great article, but I find this statement alarmingly ill-informed:
    “We found a preponderance of dung beetles specific to human feces,” Lowman says. “So obviously the system is being degraded even without intent.”

    Certainly, open defecation poses nasty disease risks to humans, but dung beetles are the most efficient way to return nitrogen and other nutrients in manure to soils, and a central part of organic pasture agriculture. Don’t let western cultural taboos drive ecology- using the forest as an open latrine is very likely restoring the nutrients lost to foraging and firewood collection. So long as residents continue to use forest products, some method of restoring nutrients to the forest must be found. Pit latrines aren’t a good way to do that.

    Pit latrines may be a step forward for human health, but they could be a step back for the health of the forest. Dung beetles clean up feces fast. Research the rate of fecal-oral disease before recommending any sanitation changes, and know that soap and hand washing may do more than toilets. These forests have survived sixteen centuries, and unless people are getting sick, the system is working. If the system isn’t working, consider composting toilets that abate disease risks while allowing land application.

    more on dung beetles:
    http://attra.ncat.org/attra-pub/dungbeetle.html

    A great, easy-to-make and low water use sink:
    http://www.wot.utwente.nl/publications/tippy-tap.pdf

    • Amy R says:

      Very thoughtful comment, which helps this conversation go forward, re composting toilets and low-water use sink. I wondered about the statement too, which seemed to decry the preponderance of dung beetles in the church forests. And I was thinking, would dung beetles go down into pit latrines. And when the pit latrine is full, then what: they will get full eventually – they always do!

    • mathew says:

      After contacting Meg Lowman I want to say that the sanitation situation does sound really desperate. clearly toilets are needed.

  15. DelDav says:

    “In America, some fundamental Christians believe that man has a God-given right to use the earth and all its resources to meet their needs.”

    Two things about this opening sentence really bother me. First is the casual and unsupported slander of American Christians. I defy you to find one Christian, fundamentalist or not, who supports using “all” of the earth’s resources. Much more common among such people are discussion about being “good stewards”

    The second thing that bothers me is that it trades in smug bigotry for no good reason other than to land a cheap shot. It does nothing to make your story better.

    • I’m reminded of a song called “This Beautiful Earth” by a duo of Australian Christian musicians. An excerpt:

      We need to take the time to look around
      We need to take the time to sit down
      And drink in the presence of God through creation
      In a forest cathedral with a mountain its spire

      Another excerpt:

      We must nurture the Earth that nurtures its people
      And treasure the Earth and keep it from harm
      We must nurture the mystery and not lose the wonder
      Of a seed, of a forest, of a star, of God’s love

      I make no comment on the fundamentalism issue.

    • “First is the casual and unsupported slander of American Christians.”

      She wrote “some” fundamentalist Christians. some < all

  16. Jon Summers says:

    Don’t miss the PPT presentation, but there is a mangled url in the second cite of the articles’s SOURCE section pointing to the PPT presentation. The last part of the url reads as
    Alemayehu%2520Wassie%2520Eshete%2520PPT.pdf
    It can be edited changing each(3) %2520 to %20 to read
    Alemayehu%20Wassie%20Eshete%20PPT.pdf
    The corrected link to the presentation is (if comment software doesnt mangle it):
    http://www.ser.org/files/ppt/Alemayehu%20Wassie%20Eshete%20PPT.pdf

  17. Pingback: Saving the 1600-year-old "church forests" of Ethiopia (scroll down for great photos) - Christian Forums

  18. Pingback: Church Forests « A Pastor's Notes

  19. Pingback: Weekly Roundup 2011.03.06 « ZENOSPHERE

  20. Pingback: buiding up not out, blue boat wallpaper, punished while accused « inkbluesky

  21. Pingback: The Word for Church is Forest | Notes from The Pondonome

  22. Pingback: links for 2011-03-08 | Green+Geek

  23. Pingback: Ethiopia’s Church Forests | Trinity Magazine Online

  24. I had the same reaction as others to your first line. I almost did not read the rest of the story because of its narrow minded slap at all devout Christians.
    Yet, because Ed Yong said I should, I kept reading and was moved by the rest of the article. How ironic that you celebrate the spirituality contained in the forest churches, but with that first line have ensured that many who would otherwise invest resources to help these forest churches won’t read any further to discover the beauty therein.

    Every Ethiopian I’ve met in the Washington DC area professes Christianity. They also convey and peace and understanding that comes from a very old embrace of the faith that came to them in the first century after the death of Christ. The people of Ethiopia don’t have much going for them in the kind of trade the world values, but their adherence to ancient traditions and deep spirituality sustains them through much suffering.

    My prayer is that your article will help raise support for the forest churches. If you want help from American Christians though, you might want to do a little editing so they will read the entire thing.

  25. Pingback: Saving Ethiopia’s “Church Forests” | s i l o u a n

  26. Pingback: Inspired by life in the treetops « Wild Muse

  27. Pingback: Till we meet again… « Wild Muse

  28. Midnight Rambler says:

    Great article; found it (late) though the Open Laboratory nomination. And in case anyone coming across it now is somehow unaware of the attitude that is the source of the first line:

    Natural Resources and God’s BountyA secular society will lack faith in God’s providence and consequently men will find fewer natural resources. The secular or socialist has a limited resource mentality and views the world as a pie (there is only so much) that needs to be cut up so that everyone can get a piece. In contrast, the Christian knows that the potential in God is unlimited and that there is no shortage of resources in God’s earth. The resources are waiting to be tapped.

  29. Pingback: Best Science Writing Online « OPTICS & MODERN PHYSICS

  30. Pingback: Open Lab 2012: And the Finalists Are….

  31. Pingback: Church forests in Ethiopia

  32. Pingback: Church forests in Ethiopia - FarmIQ

  33. Worku Aberra says:

    Dear Delene,
    As an Ethiopian living in Montreal, I was deeply touched by your article. I remember as a child one such forest, about 20 kms southwest of Addis Ababa. It was large and included a number of wild animals, but when I went back to Ethiopia last summer, after 20 years, I realized that it has considerably shrunk. Unfortunately, given the economic hardship that the people living around these forests face, I feel that it is a matter of time before these forests disappear. But articles like yours can help in raising people’s awareness so that something can be done to prevent the loss of these beautiful forests. Thank you very much for your contribution to such a worthwhile cause.

    Worku

  34. Pingback: Open Lab 2012 / The Best of Science Writing Online 2012 « Wild Muse

  35. DeLene says:

    For those interested, this post was selected for inclusion in The Best of Science Writing Online 2012, a published anthology which will come out in fall of 2012 and includes science blog posts written in 2011. The last paragaph of my post announcing this includes a discussion of my thoughts on the lede:
    http://sciencetrio.wordpress.com/2012/01/17/open-lab-2012-the-best-of-science-writing-online-2012/

  36. Pingback: Baskeet Landmarks: St Mikael Church | Basket to Ethiopia

  37. Pingback: Church Forest: A documentary in the making | Basket to Ethiopia

  38. Pingback: The Garden of Eden, Coming to a Church Near You…? (Genesis 2:8-15) | The Left Hand of Ehud: Matt's Bible Blog

  39. Pingback: Ethiopia’s Church Forests | Nicholas C. Kawa